Object's details: Approbatory gloss to the judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court of December 1, 2020, II OSK 1580/18 – The inadmissibility of a restrictive interpretation of the phrase “access from the same public road”

Provider:Platforma Otwartych Czasopism Naukowych UAM

Description

Title:
Approbatory gloss to the judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court of December 1, 2020, II OSK 1580/18 – The inadmissibility of a restrictive interpretation of the phrase “access from the same public road”
Creator:
Mączyński, Maciej
Description:
The cited judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court focuses on the meaning of the expression “access from the same public road”. The judgment of the Court of Second Instance deserves to be approved because the recitals of this judgment take into account the right to develop the plot to which the investor holds the legal title, the broad understanding of ‘neighborhood’, as well as the values that constitute the ratio legis of the Act on spatial planning and development.The rationale of the Supreme Administrative Court’s decision results primarily from the fact that a narrow understanding of neighbourhood which is prompted by the linguistic interpretation was not deemed sufficient. Referring to the jurisprudence, and above all the legislative activity of the Supreme Administrative Court and the doctrine of administrative law, it should have been concluded that the effects of the linguistic interpretation were legitimately checked from the point of view of the legislator’s goal when enacting the Act on Spatial Planning and Development. Therefore, it was necessary to make a purposive interpretation that justiﬁes the need to take into account the right to develop a building plot, take into consideration values such as spatial order, sustainable development, ownership and public interest, as well as the interest of third parties.The position of the judgment under review is not uniform in the jurisprudence. However, it does take into account the need to weigh up the disputed interests. Although the right of ownership is signiﬁcantly limited in the planning and legal regulations, it is unacceptable to deprive it of its use only due to the assumption that neighbourhood should be understood as the contact of two plots or their access to the same public road.
Object availability:
free access
Rights: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0 ;
Prawa autorskie (c) 2022 Maciej Mączyński
Date:
2022.08.30
Type:
info:eu-repo/semantics/article;
info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
Language:
Polish
Source:
Studia Prawa Publicznego; No. 2 (38) (2022); 168-181;
Studia Prawa Publicznego; Nr 2 (38) (2022); 168-181;
2720-2445;
2300-3936
Format:
application/pdf
Publisher:
Adam Mickiewicz University Poznan
Relation: http://pressto.amu.edu.pl/index.php/spp/article/view/35055/30267
Subject:
neighbourhood;
spatial order;
ownership;
purposive interpretation
Identifier: http://pressto.amu.edu.pl/index.php/spp/article/view/35055
Data provider:
Platforma Otwartych Czasopism Naukowych UAM

Similar objects

Approbatory gloss to the judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court of December 1, 2020, II OSK 1580/18 – The inadmissibility of a restrictive interpretation of the phrase “access from the same public road”

Creator:Mączyński, Maciej

Date:2022.08.30

Type:text

Ład przestrzenny w Piotrkowie Trybunalskim

Creator:Rudalska, Katarzyna | Bartosiewicz, Bartosz

Date:2021.02.24 | 2019.12.30

Type:image

Tourism versus spatial order: mutual relations

Creator:Meyer, Beata

Date:2015.08.11 | 2012.01.31

Type:other

Badanie spójności przestrzennej w gminach podmiejskich aglomeracji poznańskiej na przykładzie Lubonia

Creator:Kołata, Joanna | Zierke, Piotr

Date:2021.02.24 | 2019.03.30

Type:image

A microplan of spatial development – analysis of chosen aspects

Creator:Ilków, Diana

Date:2016.12.15

Type:text

Efficacy, impact and English legal history

Creator:Watkin, Thomas Glyn

Date:2021.02.16 | 2020.04.02

Type:image

A multidimensional analysis of spatial order in public spaces: a case study of the town Morąg, Poland

Creator:Szczepańska, Agnieszka | Pietrzyk, Katarzyna

Date:2019.06.04

Type:text

Kształtowanie ładu przestrzennego jako zadanie badawcze geografii historycznej

Creator:Kozłowski, Leszek

Date:2017.04.04 | 2016

Type:image

Federacja Bibliotek Cyfrowych

Object's details: Approbatory gloss to the judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court of December 1, 2020, II OSK 1580/18 – The inadmissibility of a restrictive interpretation of the phrase “access from the same public road”

Description

Similar objects